Skip to main content

Employment Law

Constructive Dismissal in Ontario: When a Workplace Change Raises Legal Questions

What to review when your employer changes your pay, duties, hours or work location, and why the timing of your response matters.

Illustrative photograph of a man seated at a commuter rail station, with the Legal Route logo.

Illustrative image. The person and scene are fictional.

Ask About a Change to Your JobCall 905-283-8514

Constructive dismissal can arise when your employer substantially changes an essential term of your job in breach of the employment contract. It can also arise when the employer’s conduct as a whole shows it no longer intends to honour the contract. Review what you agreed to and how the change affects you before deciding how to respond.

This guide is for non-unionized employees whose jobs are governed by Ontario employment law. Unionized and federally regulated employees may have different rights and processes.

Key takeaways

  • Compare the change with the terms you agreed to and assess its effect on your pay, duties or working arrangements.
  • Check when the change was announced, when it takes effect and when your employer expects a reply. Your response and its timing can matter.
  • For a layoff, review both the employer’s contractual authority and Ontario’s statutory rules on duration.

If you inquire, say what changed and give any deadline to reply or sign. Legal Route checks conflicts and availability and explains the consultation scope and any fee before you book. An inquiry does not retain the firm or extend a deadline.

The Supreme Court of Canada identifies two ways an employer’s conduct can amount to a constructive dismissal. The first starts with a unilateral act that breaches the employment contract. The question is whether a reasonable person in your circumstances would have seen that act as substantially changing an essential term.

The second looks at the employer’s conduct as a whole. A series of acts can show that the employer no longer intends to be bound by the contract. The test is objective. The history of the employment relationship and the context of each event can matter.

Which workplace changes deserve a closer look?

  • Pay and compensation. Compare base pay, commissions, benefits and how each is earned. A change to a pay formula can affect what you receive even when your base salary stays the same.
  • Hours and scheduling. Look at reductions in guaranteed hours, moves from full-time to part-time work or a change to an agreed schedule.
  • Role and responsibilities. Compare your actual duties, decision-making authority and reporting relationships before and after a reassignment or demotion.
  • Work location. Consider the terms about location, remote work or transfers and the practical effect of the change.

Example of a reduction in hours

An employee hired for a regular full-time schedule is told that their hours will drop to three days a week on an ongoing basis. The agreed hours, any scheduling clause, the duration of the change and the effect on earnings all help determine whether the change is substantial.

What did your employment terms allow?

Read the offer, employment agreement and later amendments together. Look for terms about pay, transfers, hours and changes to duties. Written messages about how the job would work and the way the arrangement operated in practice may also help explain what the parties agreed to.

Check whether the employer has proposed a new term, directed that it will take effect or given notice of a change. The language of the agreement, the scope of any flexibility clause, the notice given and your response can affect the analysis.

How does a temporary layoff fit?

A layoff raises two questions. The terms of your employment help determine whether your employer has authority to lay you off. Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 sets out when a layoff is treated as termination because it exceeds the statutory limits. Ontario also has an extended layoff process for some non-unionized employees. It requires a written agreement and approval by the Director of Employment Standards.

Even a layoff that falls within the statutory limits can raise a constructive dismissal issue if the employment contract gives the employer no right to impose it. Bring the layoff letter, any recall date or benefit information and the terms of your employment to a review.

What should you record before responding?

Prepare a short timeline with the date the change was communicated, when it starts and what you were asked to sign or do. Keep copies of records you are entitled to access, such as your agreement, pay statements, schedules and written communications about the change. Record what you already said or signed.

Continuing to work under the new arrangement, signing revised terms or delaying a response can affect whether you are treated as having accepted the change. Flag any signing deadline your employer gives you. Whether you responded within a reasonable time depends on the circumstances, including when you learned what would change. Get advice promptly before deciding whether to accept the change or resign.

What rights could be affected?

Ontario’s Employment Standards Act, 2000 can treat constructive dismissal as termination if the employee resigns in response within a reasonable period. Statutory notice or termination pay and statutory severance pay are separate entitlements with different eligibility rules.

Rights under the employment contract or common law may also be relevant, including compensation tied to a notice period. The agreement, the facts, the compensation you received and any duty to mitigate losses can affect what is available. Have the applicable deadlines and options reviewed before deciding whether to make a claim or sign a release.

As part of its employment law services for layoffs and changes to employment, Legal Route can review the agreement, the proposed change and its timing, and explain how a response might affect your options. If the employer has offered new terms or a separation package, the firm can review those documents within the agreed scope. Legal Route’s legal services are provided by lawyers licensed by the Law Society of Ontario.

What to have ready for an initial inquiry

Have the employer’s name, the date you started, a short summary of what changed and the next deadline. Say whether you have signed new terms or left the job. Wait for secure delivery instructions before sending an agreement, pay statements or sensitive workplace records.

Employment consultations in Brampton and across Ontario

In Brampton. In-person consultations are available by arrangement at our Brampton office, 2074 Steeles Avenue East, Unit 17.

Toronto and the GTA. We assist with employment matters across the region, including Burlington and Pickering.

Across Ontario. Virtual consultations are available for suitable matters. See our Ontario service areas for appointment options.

Frequently asked questions about constructive dismissal

Is there a percentage pay cut that automatically qualifies?

Courts assess whether the change is substantial in context. The amount, duration, effect on your overall compensation and terms of the agreement can all matter.

Can a return-to-office requirement raise a constructive dismissal issue?

It can, depending on the agreement and circumstances. Review how remote work was arranged, any reserved right to change location and the effect of the requirement. If remote work was part of a disability-related accommodation, the change may also raise a separate human rights question.

Can a change in duties matter if my job title stays the same?

Yes. A review can look at the responsibilities and authority you actually had, what changed and how central those duties were to the position.

What if I have already resigned?

Bring your resignation, the messages leading up to it and the dates. Whether the resignation was a response to the change and how soon it followed are important to the review.

Can workplace harassment be relevant?

Workplace conduct can be relevant when assessing whether the employer’s actions as a whole show that it no longer intends to honour the contract. Harassment can also raise separate duties and rights. See our Ontario workplace harassment guide.

Talk to Legal Route about a change to your job

Tell us what changed, when it was announced and whether you have a deadline to respond. We can explain what a consultation would cover.

Ask About Your Workplace Change

Call 905-283-8514 or see our Brampton office and appointment details. An inquiry does not establish a lawyer-client relationship or confirm that the firm has accepted the matter.

Official resources

This guide provides general legal information. Your options and deadlines depend on your employment terms, the facts and the laws that apply to your job.