Skip to main content

Construction Law

Construction Adjudication in Ontario: When a Payment Dispute Arises

When an Ontario construction payment dispute may fit interim adjudication and what to review before proceeding.

Illustrative photograph of a construction professional wearing protective equipment in a partially finished commercial interior, with the Legal Route logo.

Illustrative image. The person and setting are fictional.

Discuss Construction AdjudicationCall 905-283-8514

Construction adjudication can provide a relatively quick, binding interim decision about an eligible Ontario construction dispute, including many payment disagreements. Whether it is available and commercially worthwhile depends on the contract, the issue, the project history, the evidence and the applicable deadlines. It does not automatically replace lien rights, settlement discussions or a final court or arbitration decision.

This guide focuses on owners, contractors and subcontractors considering adjudication under Ontario’s Construction Act. The rules changed on January 1, 2026. Contract and procurement dates, transition provisions and the type of claim need review. Some bond disputes involve additional rules.

Key takeaways

  • Check whether the parties, dispute and timing fit the applicable adjudication rules.
  • A short process makes clear contracts, payment records and evidence of the work important.
  • An interim determination can require payment even while other parts of the dispute remain unresolved.

For an initial inquiry, identify your role, the project, the disputed amount and any notice or deadline received. Legal Route checks conflicts and availability and explains the consultation scope and any fee before you book. An inquiry does not retain the firm or extend a deadline.

Which construction disputes may qualify?

The current regulation identifies matters that can be referred to adjudication. Examples include the value of services or materials, payment for work or changes, certain non-payment notices, specified set-offs and holdback payment.

Some questions about scope of work, a price change or an extension of time can also be addressed where resolving them is reasonably necessary to determine another matter that may be adjudicated. That does not make every disagreement on a project eligible without further review.

The contracting relationships matter. A dispute between an owner and contractor may differ from one between a contractor and subcontractor. The governing documents, the parties against whom relief is sought and any special statutory route need to be identified. Parties may also agree to adjudicate matters within the applicable framework.

Why should the project dates be reviewed promptly?

The current rules include a 90-day limit after a contract is completed, abandoned or terminated, unless the parties agree otherwise. For a subcontract, the relevant 90-day period can run from an earlier specified event, including certified completion or the subcontractor’s last supply. The precise trigger and any transition provision need assessment.

Once adjudication starts, the timetable is compressed. The usual statutory period for the determination is 30 days after the adjudicator receives the required claimant documents, subject to permitted extensions. That is not a promise that every dispute finishes 30 days after the first notice.

A recipient should raise any notice and the date it arrived promptly. The adjudicator’s directions and document deadlines matter to the opportunity to present a response. Waiting for an informal payment discussion does not establish that an applicable deadline has been extended.

What evidence can affect the payment dispute?

The adjudicator needs a clear account of what was agreed, what happened and why money is claimed or withheld. Relevant records may include:

  • The contract or subcontract, scope documents and payment terms.
  • Invoices, payment applications, certifications, payment records and non-payment notices.
  • Change orders, instructions, approvals and correspondence about extra work.
  • Site records, photographs, delivery records and evidence of alleged deficiencies.
  • A clear breakdown of the amount disputed and any credits or set-offs.

For example, a subcontractor may claim extra payment for work requested on site while the contractor disputes its scope or value. The original scope, instruction history, pricing and evidence that the work was supplied help frame the disagreement. An invoice alone may not explain those issues.

The adjudicator sets an appropriate process within the legal framework. Some matters proceed on documents; others may involve an oral hearing, a site visit or additional expertise. The evidence and preparation should fit the issues and the process actually directed.

What does an interim determination mean for payment and costs?

A determination is binding on the parties until the matter is determined by a court or arbitration, or the parties resolve it by a written agreement. Calling it “interim” does not make compliance optional.

Under the current Act, an amount ordered to be paid is generally due within 15 days after the determination is communicated to the parties, subject to the applicable holdback requirements. Non-payment can raise interest and enforcement issues.

Judicial review is a limited court process requiring permission and subject to short deadlines. It is not an ordinary rehearing of the dispute. A challenge does not automatically suspend the determination.

Adjudicator fees and legal preparation are separate costs. The usual rules provide for sharing the adjudicator’s fee and each party bearing its own costs, with statutory exceptions for specified improper conduct. A favourable determination does not guarantee full recovery of legal expenses or actual collection.

How does adjudication fit with liens and other proceedings?

Adjudication, a construction lien and a civil claim serve different purposes. An adjudication does not itself register or perfect a lien. Lien preservation, perfection and enforcement have their own requirements, and their timing needs to be considered alongside the adjudication rules.

An eligible dispute may be adjudicated while related court or arbitration proceedings are ongoing, subject to the governing rules and whether the dispute has already been finally determined. An interim decision and a final resolution should be distinguished.

The practical assessment also considers the amount at stake, available evidence, expected costs, payment prospects and whether a negotiated resolution is realistic. No single route is appropriate for every unpaid construction account.

What should you have ready for a consultation?

Have the contract, payment records, notices and important project correspondence available. Note the contract and procurement dates, when work was last supplied, and any completion, abandonment, termination or certification dates.

Tell us whether a lien, court claim, arbitration or earlier adjudication is involved. Identify any received notice and response date. Keep detailed commercial records out of the initial inquiry and wait for secure document instructions.

How can Legal Route help with construction adjudication?

Legal Route’s construction adjudication services include assessing whether a dispute fits the process, reviewing the records, preparing claims or responses and representing parties as appropriate. We also consider how the dispute relates to payment notices, liens, settlement and other proceedings.

Legal Route’s legal services are provided by lawyers licensed by the Law Society of Ontario. Assistance depends on conflicts, availability and an agreed scope of work. We explain the issues and recovery risks without promising an outcome.

Where can you discuss an Ontario construction dispute?

Brampton office. In-person appointments are available by arrangement at 2074 Steeles Avenue East, Unit 17, 2nd floor, Brampton. See our office and appointment details.

Toronto and the GTA. We serve clients across Toronto, Peel, York, Halton and Durham, including Mississauga and Milton. The firm’s physical office is in Brampton.

Across Ontario. Virtual appointments are available for suitable matters. Document, identification, site and attendance requirements depend on the work involved. Explore our Ontario service areas.

Frequently asked questions about construction adjudication

Is adjudication the same as mediation?

No. An adjudicator determines the dispute submitted within the applicable process. A mediator helps parties try to reach their own agreement.

Can adjudication still be available after work has ended?

It may be, within the applicable statutory period or an agreement permitted by the Act. Contract and subcontract triggers differ. Completion, termination and last-supply dates should be reviewed promptly.

Does the other party always have to agree?

Consent is not generally required for an eligible statutory adjudication. A dispute outside the prescribed categories, or a special route, may involve additional requirements or agreement.

Can a party ignore a determination while starting a court case?

No. The determination remains binding unless the law provides otherwise. Starting another proceeding does not, by itself, remove the payment obligation or create a stay.

Will starting adjudication protect my lien?

Adjudication does not itself preserve or perfect a lien. The lien documents, deadlines and any interaction between statutory processes require a separate assessment.

Discuss construction adjudication with Legal Route

Facing a construction payment dispute or received an adjudication notice? Tell us your role, the project, the amount in dispute and any date that needs attention. We can explain whether we can assist and the next step.

Discuss Construction Adjudication Call 905-283-8514

An inquiry does not establish a lawyer-client relationship or confirm that Legal Route has accepted your matter or a deadline. Please wait for secure instructions before sending documents.

Official resources

This guide provides general legal information about Ontario construction adjudication. Advice depends on the contract, project dates, applicable transition provisions, dispute and related proceedings.