Skip to main content

Civil Litigation

Breach of Contract in Ontario: What to Review Before Starting a Claim

How to review the agreement, document what went wrong and weigh your options before taking legal action.

Illustrative photograph of a shop owner comparing two display shelves of different sizes beside an open carton, with the Legal Route logo.

Illustrative image. The person and scene are fictional.

Discuss your contract disputeCall 905-283-8514

A breach of contract occurs when a party fails to perform an obligation under an enforceable agreement. Before starting a claim in Ontario, identify the term you say was breached, what shows it was breached and what remedy you can support. Check any notice requirements and the deadline to start a proceeding early.

This guide is for individuals and businesses weighing a claim over an unpaid amount, late or defective delivery, unfinished work or another disputed obligation.

Key takeaways

  • Review the agreement as it stood when the problem arose, including any accepted changes.
  • Check whether the contract requires written notice, a chance to correct the problem or a particular dispute process.
  • Compare what full performance would have cost or delivered with what actually happened. Keep records of losses, credits and steps to limit the damage.

When you inquire, flag the earliest date you think may matter. Legal Route checks conflicts and availability and explains the scope and any fee before you book. An inquiry does not retain the firm or extend a deadline.

What was agreed, and who agreed to it?

Start with the signed contract, accepted quote or order, plus any schedules, specifications and later changes. If there is no signed document, a contract can sometimes be shown through conversations, messages or the parties’ conduct. A binding contract generally requires an offer, acceptance, an exchange of value such as mutual promises, and an intention to be legally bound assessed from what the parties said and did. Some agreements have additional form requirements.

Confirm the legal names of the parties. A trade name, the company named on the order and the person who signed it may point to different people or entities. If you think someone personally guaranteed payment, find the guarantee and check what it covers.

Which obligation was breached?

Identify the term and the date performance was due. Then match it to what happened. If you say a delivery was late, check whether the date was firm, whether you agreed to an extension and whether your own approval or payment had to come first. For defective goods or work, compare what you received with the agreed specifications or scope.

Build a short timeline with a record for each key event. Save complete email threads, messages, invoices, delivery slips, inspection records and dated photos. Include correspondence about changes and any explanation the other party gave. For disputes primarily about payment, see our guide to unpaid business invoices.

What does the contract require before you act?

Read the clauses on notice, default and termination together. The contract may require notice by a certain date, to a named recipient and by a specified method. It may give the other party time to correct the problem. Keep a copy of anything you sent or received and proof of delivery.

Check these terms before withholding payment, cancelling an order or treating the agreement as ended. Whether a breach allows you to end the contract depends on the terms and the seriousness of the breach. Ending it prematurely can create a claim against you.

What loss can you document?

Contract damages generally aim to put you in the financial position you would have been in if the agreement had been performed. Depending on the circumstances, the reasonable extra cost of replacement goods or work may form part of a claim. You need evidence that the breach caused the loss and that the type of loss was reasonably within the parties’ contemplation when they made the agreement. Check for terms that limit liability or exclude specific losses.

Keep quotes, invoices and proof of payment. Account for credits, refunds and costs you avoided. Record reasonable steps to limit the loss, such as asking for a timely correction or comparing replacement quotes. This is called mitigation.

Example with a shipment of display shelves

A shop orders shelves to agreed dimensions, but the shipment arrives in a different size. The approved specifications, photos and delivery record help show the mismatch. If the shop can obtain comparable replacements for $1,500 and no longer owes the original $1,200 price, the extra purchase cost is $300. Whether that cost is recoverable depends on the contract, notice and the steps the shop took to resolve the problem.

What deadline applies to your claim?

Ontario’s basic limitation period is generally two years from when the claim was discovered. Discovery involves when you knew or reasonably ought to have known that a loss occurred, that an act or omission of the person you would claim against caused or contributed to it, and that a proceeding would be an appropriate way to seek a remedy. The start date can be disputed, and exceptions and other deadlines can apply.

Track contractual notice deadlines separately. Sending a demand letter or discussing settlement does not automatically stop the limitation clock. If a date is close or unclear, get advice promptly about when a proceeding must be started and where it belongs.

Which process fits the dispute?

Check the agreement for required steps such as negotiation or mediation, and for clauses about arbitration or where a claim must be heard. A valid arbitration clause that covers the dispute can require arbitration. Limitation rules can apply to arbitration, too. A negotiated payment, repair or replacement may be possible if the parties can agree on terms.

If court is the right forum, Ontario Small Claims Court generally hears claims for money or the return of personal property up to $50,000, excluding interest and costs. The remedy, amount and contract terms can affect the forum. Our Ontario Small Claims Court guide explains that process. When weighing whether to proceed, consider the value of the claim, the cost and time involved and the likelihood of collecting if you succeed.

As part of its contract and commercial disputes services, Legal Route can review the agreement and evidence, assess notice and limitation issues, and explain the options for resolving the dispute. Depending on the agreed scope, the firm can help with a demand, settlement discussions or representation in a civil proceeding. Legal Route’s legal services are provided by lawyers licensed by the Law Society of Ontario.

What to have ready for an initial inquiry

Have the parties’ names, a brief timeline, any known deadline and a description of the outcome you want. Gather the contract and changes, notices, key correspondence and records of loss. Wait for secure delivery instructions before sending documents.

Civil litigation consultations in Brampton and across Ontario

In Brampton. In-person consultations are available by arrangement at our Brampton office, 2074 Steeles Avenue East, Unit 17.

Toronto and the GTA. We assist with contract disputes across the region, including Mississauga, Markham and Oakville.

Across Ontario. Virtual consultations are available for suitable matters. See our Ontario service areas for appointment options.

Frequently asked questions about breach of contract

Can emails show that a contract was made?

Yes. Emails can record an offer, acceptance and the terms. Read the full exchange. A message that says any agreement is subject to signing a final contract can matter, as can any legal requirements for that type of agreement.

Do I have to send a demand letter before starting a claim?

It depends on the contract and the nature of the claim. A letter may help put the dispute on record and give the other side a chance to respond. If a formal notice is required, check that any letter meets the applicable timing, content and delivery requirements.

Can I claim lost sales?

Lost profits may be recoverable if supported by evidence and the legal requirements are met. A sales forecast alone may leave questions about what you would actually have earned after expenses. The contract may limit or exclude some losses.

Can I ask for the work to be completed?

Completion can be part of a settlement. An order requiring performance is a distinct remedy, generally available only where money damages would be inadequate and the circumstances justify it. The remedy you seek can affect where you bring the claim.

Will the other side have to pay my lawyer’s fees if I win?

A court may award costs, subject to the rules and circumstances of the proceeding. The award may cover only part of what you spent. Check whether the contract also addresses legal costs.

Discuss your contract dispute with Legal Route

Tell us what was agreed, what went wrong and any looming deadline. We can explain what a consultation would cover.

Request a contract dispute consultation

Call 905-283-8514 or see our Brampton office and appointment details. An inquiry does not establish a lawyer-client relationship or confirm that the firm has accepted the matter.

Official resources

This article provides general legal information. The agreement, evidence and applicable deadlines can affect the options in your case.